How reliable is Maserati? An unbiased look at the luxury brand

Concerned about buying a brand-new car but want to make sure you’re making the right choice? Maybe you’re looking for a luxury vehicle that will suit your needs but are worried about its reliability? This article will focus on answering the question “How reliable is Maserati?”, as well as reviewing individual vehicles, to help you make the best and most educated decision possible. 

Maserati is known for producing luxurious and fast cars. Their logo is shaped like Neptune’s trident, inspiring a vision of luxury, elegance and speed.

Founded by four brothers in Modena, Italy in 1914, the company was purchased by Fiat Chrysler Automobiles (FCA) in 1993.

In recent years, Maserati has become more popular. Since 2013 the company has experienced an increase in sales and in 2017 they sold over 51,000 units globally.

But, despite bespoke interiors, high performance and Italian style, there is one thing that plagues Maserati, and that’s dependability.

In this article, we look at how reliable the exclusive Italian brand is to run, taking into account the average cost of repairs, the amount of time that the cars are off the road due to faults, and the general wear and tear you can expect to experience with your new Maserati.

Is Maserati reliable?

The brand isn’t known for being overly reliable, suffering several issues, with the most common faults being electrical or affecting the axle and suspension.

Unfortunately, while Maserati is becoming increasingly popular among buyers, its reliability has not improved. Since 2016, Maserati has repeatedly earned a low reliability rating in the ReliabilityIndex rankings, coming 40th out of 40 brands.

In the most recent ReliabilityIndex rankings, the luxury manufacturer has earned a rating of ‘Poor’. In 2016 their point score in the Index was 697, in 2019 this has increased to an incredibly impressive 774 (though in this case, the more points a brand has, the lower the reliability rating).

The next closest manufacturer to Maserati is another luxury brand, Bentley, which has a reliability index score of 530 (just 1 point more than they earned in 2016).

How reliable is the Maserati GranTurismo?

The GranTurismo is probably one of the best-known models by Maserati and almost 4500 of them have been sold across Europe since 2010.

Focusing more specifically on the Maserati GranTurismo, we can see that when it comes to reliability, it fares slightly better than when looking at the brand overall.

According to the latest information from ReliabilityIndex, the GranTurismo has a rating of 748, so it’s still not incredible, but an improvement on 774. Though reliability is considered low for Maserati, many of the issues that contribute to the low score the manufacturer has been awarded occur later in the vehicle’s life.

So, if Maserati is your dream and you are considering getting a lease, it’s worth considering purchasing a maintenance package. There are ways to make your dream a reality without hurting your wallet.

As with any luxury vehicle, the repair costs are not kind to the bank balance, with the average working out at £1,157.70. While being repaired you can also expect to be waiting around a little, with repairs taking almost 5 hours, on average.

The key issue you should expect to encounter with the GranTurismo with the axle and suspension, which accounts for 38.30% of the car’s problems.

Another thing to consider when looking to purchase the Maserati GranTurismo, if you’ve been won over by the sleek styling of the powerful car, is the running costs.

Maserati claims you’ll get 20 mpg combined (that’s 13 in cities, 29 on motorways), but in reality, this will be much lower if you use the impressive 4.7-litre motor to its full potential. The car will also be in the top band when it comes to Vehicle Excise Duty due to CO₂ emissions of 331g/km. And, as with any sports car with the power that you can get from the GranTurismo, you can expect the insurance to be extremely expensive.

When you register your new car with the DVLA (in the UK) you will also find you are expected to pay a £390 per year surcharge (once the car is 12 months old, and until it turns six) as the Maserati GranTurismo has a list price of over £40,000.

Is the Maserati Ghibli reliable?

The Maserati Ghibli is a very popular model from the Italian brand if the 22,684 sold across Europe since 2014 is anything to go by.

However, just as with the GranTurismo, there are issues with reliability, with reviews from owners proving very mixed. Many specifically cite reliability as the issue they have had with their new vehicle.

Some have had trouble with the brakes, while others have found that the battery drains too quickly. One owner even stated that their Ghibli had been in the garage four times in the first twelve months.

In their own road test of the Ghibli, AutoExpress found that the car was lacking in build quality, missing the precision of the German equivalents (specifically mentioning the BMW 5-Series). There were also issues with the infotainment system, power-steering and brakes.

That said, as with every vehicle and every owner, some Maserati Ghibli drivers have had no problems at all with the reliability and when asked, gave it five stars.

When it comes to safety, the 2013 version of the Ghibli rated well, earning five stars from Euro NCAP for the multiple safety features, including airbags, pedestrian protection and safety assist.

The Ghibli isn’t exactly low-cost to run, however, expenditure isn’t as high as for the GranTurismo.

Maserati claims that the Ghibli can do 48mpg, however, this depends greatly on the model selected. Miles per gallon varies from 29 to 48 mpg combined (20-37 city, 40-58 highway).

If you select the lower-powered twin-turbo V6 petrol engine with 350bhp, indications are that you will get 32mpg and CO₂ emissions are 207g/km, putting you at the higher end of the vehicle excise duty table, with the first payment upon registration amounting to £1,280.

If you decide that you would like the higher-powered Ghibli S with 404bhp then the miles per gallon drop to 29mpg combined and emissions of 223g/km CO₂.

Like the GranTurismo, the Ghibli has a list price of over £40,000 and, therefore, will have a surcharge of £390 per year for years three to six.

Is the Maserati Levante a reliable car?

With Maserati dipping into the SUV market with the Levante, Maserati seems to be branching out from its usual vehicles, such as sports cars and luxury saloons. This full-size SUV, measuring over 5 metres long, is bigger than its rivals but with its appearance resembling coupés, it manages to hide its bulk quite well. 

Using a modified version of Ghibli’s platform, you’d expect this vehicle to have improved on its reliability. But is this the case? 

While Euro NCAP hasn’t crash-tested it yet as previously mentioned, it shares most of its mechanical architecture with the Ghibli which received 5 stars for safety when it was tested by Euro NCAP back in 2013. 

AutoExpress awarded this vehicle a 3.5 out of 5 stars for reliability and safety, criticising the build quality, saying it wasn’t “as good as you might expect”. However, they do highlight and praise the three-year, unlimited mileage warranty.

This warranty beats its rivals’ warranty, such as the Audi Q7’s 3-year/60,000-mile guarantee. However, they do comment that while Porsche, BMW and Mercedes-Benz all offer the same cover, if you choose one of its rivals, you’re less likely to suffer from smaller issues – if historical data is anything to go by. 

This vehicle is available with either a petrol or diesel powertrain, both of which are 3-litre V6 powerplants. The more economical diesel has a power output of 275hp, whereas the petrol “S” form has 430hp. 

Unfortunately, this isn’t the cheapest car when it comes to running costs. The official fuel-consumption claims state that the diesel version is at 31mpg, while the petrol “S” version is at 22.4mpg. On the other hand, the CO₂ figures are 238g/km and 286g/km respectively. 

If you go with the petrol version of this vehicle, it will also put you on the higher end of the vehicle excise duty table, with the first payment upon registration amounting to £2,605. On the other side, the diesel version, with the lower CO₂ emissions, amounts to £2,220. 

Why is Maserati so unreliable?

But, why is Maserati so unreliable? They’re an exclusive brand, I hear you cry! With bespoke designs and engineering, they shouldn’t be unreliable. You’re right, in theory. But in reality, you’ll find that many luxury cars have issues when it comes to reliability.

There are a few reasons for this.

One of the main reasons they place so far down on the reliability tables is that when they do go wrong, the cost of repairs is quite high.

Maseratis can also take a long time to repair as their parts are harder to source and replace due to the limited number of suppliers of rarer components. These two factors bring down the manufacturer’s dependability and therefore, reduce their reliability score in comparison with other brands.

As much as it is a great thing, and adds to the uniqueness of Maserati, another reason that ultra-luxurious brands like Maserati and Aston Martin are considered unreliable is due to one of their key selling points; bespoke engineering.

You would be forgiven for thinking that having a bespoke model made to your specific requirements would make the individual models more reliable but this isn’t always the case. More modern, mass-production manufacturing techniques make more reliable models than bespoke engineering.

Also, Maseratis aren’t really your everyday car. It’s unlikely that your Ghibli, Levante or GranTurismo is the car you use for the weekly supermarket shop! Luxury cars aren’t designed for constant use, and if they are used a lot then they do wear down quite quickly and relatively easily.

So there are quite a few reasons why Maserati might be considered unreliable.

It is also worth considering product recalls. Since 2018 there have been 58 Maserati recalls in the UK. These include:

• The front-wheel bearing can become noisy and if ignored can fail and cause loss of vehicle control 
• The right-hand door of the GranCabrio can open unexpectedly 
• The headlamp vertical beam is out of compliance on the Levante 
• Internal malfunctions of the control unit in the GranCabrio 

What are some of the common Maserati problems?

It’s always good to know what problems you may encounter further down the line with your car, so here are some common problems you may experience with your Maserati:

• Brakes
  • The brakes work, but if the fluid isn’t replaced regularly then they can get a bit wooden
• Stone chips
  • Due to the fact that Maserati models are quite low to the ground,  this means it’s possible you will end up with stone chips under the wheel arches, especially if you’re going to be driving fast (which, chances are, you will in a Maserati), so when checking for damage and wear, examine the wheel arches for stone chips, especially if you are thinking about buying a secondhand model
• Problems with the clutch
  • Some Quattroporte owners have only reached 12,000 miles before having to get their clutch replaced.

If you are looking at buying a second-hand Maserati, then it’s worth asking about these issues before you buy.

How reliable are surveys and consumer reports?

Consumer reports and surveys are an accurate way of determining how reliable a car brand is. Companies like WarrantyDirect, which sell extended warranties, record when someone makes a claim.

This data is collated and used to determine the makes and models that are dependable and which ones aren’t.

Consumer feedback is also very accurate as it gives us a good idea of what the car is like to drive on a daily basis. After all, the owners are the ones who know their cars the best. They are also the ones paying for the repairs.

That said, when you have a brand as exclusive as Maserati, you can run into some trouble. This is mainly due to the fact that there aren’t that many Maseratis on the road, therefore you do have a smaller sample size than you would for a brand such as Ford, for example.

If we look at what Which? has to say, we can see that they have very little information about Maserati as they don’t have a sample size big enough to draw conclusions from.

However, we can work with what we have and we can work with what ReliabiltyIndex (a subsidiary of WarrantyDirect) has concluded and from what owners on the likes of AutoExpress have to say.

As it stands, consumer reports and surveys are still some of the most reliable ways of determining how dependable a car is, even cars as exclusive as Maserati.

Should I buy, lease or finance a Maserati?

There’s no denying it, Maserati design and build beautiful cars. From the mid-sized Ghibli to the sleek lines of the GranTurismo.

Unlike cars such as the Ford Tourneo or VW Golf, Maserati models have been designed with luxury in mind. They are the sort of car people admire as you drive along the motorway as you head off on a weekend getaway.

Maserati knows the people who buy their cars. They know that the ones who buy or lease their cars are looking for a unique vehicle, one that is designed for the individual. Maserati’s marketing focuses on the fact that their cars are bespoke, for the aficionado.

When it comes to manufacturers like Maserati a lease is ideal. A lease with a maintenance plan takes away any concerns you may have about reliability scores and possible costly repairs.  You can have all the luxury with none of the worry.

You can drive the car for 2, 3 or 4 years, safe in the knowledge that, should anything happen, you are covered and when the lease contract ends, you can upgrade to the next model.

If you are looking at a Maserati, then you are looking for a beautiful car that doesn’t stand a chance of being ignored when it’s being driven. A Maserati is not easily forgotten.

Conclusion: How reliable is Maserati?

In conclusion, Maserati isn’t very dependable. At all. Their exclusivity means that they do not have the mass-production set-up that many of their competitors have, which goes some way in improving reliability.

This also means that they are expensive to repair and the parts can take a long time to source. But, this all comes with the package. If you get a car that is that exclusive, then it will cost you a lot to repair and the bespoke design may mean you run into trouble later down the line.

Ultimately, though, if you buy a Maserati, it’s not because you are looking for a reliable car to do your weekly shop in. You buy a Maserati because it looks good, it drives incredibly and it’s about as exclusive as you can get.

But, if you are looking for a reliable sports car, then the Maserati is slightly more reliable than Aston Martin and Ferrari.

Reliability ratings and repair costs were compiled in September 2019.

This article was last updated in October 2023.